Friday, January 11, 2019
Statement from Bennett Barsk '82
I was DC Alumni Chapter Chair (2012-2016), and a member (2014-2017) of the Alumni Board (ABD), during which I served as Outreach Committee Chair, responsible for promoting nationwide alumni engagement. I believe that the ABD erred considerably when it approved a recent constitutional change. Under the original Constitution, each chapter automatically had a seat at the ABD table. The proposed change instead creates a separate Chapter Council (including all the chapters), but only provides for at most three representatives on the ABD, thereby reducing the chapter presence on the ABD. The result: more bureaucracy and less chapter representation on the ABD.
In my opinion, this significantly diminishes the strength of the link between the ABD and the individual chapters, and solves no problem in particular, but instead creates other problems. For a chapter to be strong locally, as the DC Chapter is, it must be able to communicate with other chapters around the country (and the globe). Such communication occurs most easily and comfortably at the regular ABD meetings. All chapters should have an equal right to representation at these meetings.
I plan to vote “NO” on the proposed change to the Reed Alumni Constitution.
Statement of Connie Brand '78
As the Alumni Board representative from the SF Bay Area Chapter since 2012 I strongly object to the proposed constitutional amendments.
If passed, Chapter representation will be reduced by 2/3, and the large majority of the Alumni Board will remain undemocratically selected, “vetted” by an elite Nominating Committee. Direct Alumni participation is already limited because the Board does not perform its duty to convene an Alumni Association meeting annually. Voting for candidates does not occur if no more than one candidate is “nominated” per position.
Chapters are essential to Alumni outreach and participation and for many are an important local opportunity to meet Reedies in real life. Chapter events are organized and funded out-of-pocket by volunteers. The proposed new organization only equals more bureaucracy, further distancing alumni from the College. Historically, College support for Chapter activity has been woefully inadequate, and without funding. I seriously doubt staff could logistically support a new board.
Over a year has been wasted on this proposal at a cost of countless staff and consultant time, creating acrimony, a loss of volunteer leadership, and morale.
If passed, Chapter representation will be reduced by 2/3, and the large majority of the Alumni Board will remain undemocratically selected, “vetted” by an elite Nominating Committee. Direct Alumni participation is already limited because the Board does not perform its duty to convene an Alumni Association meeting annually. Voting for candidates does not occur if no more than one candidate is “nominated” per position.
Chapters are essential to Alumni outreach and participation and for many are an important local opportunity to meet Reedies in real life. Chapter events are organized and funded out-of-pocket by volunteers. The proposed new organization only equals more bureaucracy, further distancing alumni from the College. Historically, College support for Chapter activity has been woefully inadequate, and without funding. I seriously doubt staff could logistically support a new board.
Over a year has been wasted on this proposal at a cost of countless staff and consultant time, creating acrimony, a loss of volunteer leadership, and morale.
Statement of Johanna Colgrove '92
There are many logistical problems with this proposal covered by many others.
Any proposal created within a small dedicated group of volunteers that clearly caused great hurt, should be viewed with suspicion and probably thrown out and started over. People weren’t listened to when objections were raised. It was pushed through quickly and with no respect for the experience of chapter leaders who opposed it.
Any proposal created within a small dedicated group of volunteers that clearly caused great hurt, should be viewed with suspicion and probably thrown out and started over. People weren’t listened to when objections were raised. It was pushed through quickly and with no respect for the experience of chapter leaders who opposed it.
The current
board leadership wants to focus on young alumni, diversity &
inclusion and career networking and has decided the chapters are
irrelevant to this. Chapters have a long history of engaging with these
topics. As the board develops new efforts this needs to be done in
partnership with the chapters, not isolated from them. This proposal
creates a barrier of time, space, and communication between chapters and
the rest of the alumni board. This proposal makes working together
harder. And that will be a great setback for the alumni board and
chapters going forward in working on these important areas. I urge you
to vote no.
Memories of the Alumni Board Meeting (from Bill Nicholson '78)
A few
memories of the day the Constitutional changes were adopted by the Alumni
Board:
Some
proponents apparently claim that there was not time to carefully review the
proposed changes (resulting in drafting errors). This statement
stands in contrast to the proponents' oft-repeated line that the process had
already taken too long and therefore there was not time to look at the proposed
changes individually. The result of this false urgency was a
monolithic "take it or leave it" hurried vote.
A
number of AB members were at their first meeting due to its being scheduled
during Reunions. While they had access to much of the written record of debate
over the proposed amendments, they did not have the benefit of participating in
the many discussions that led up to the vote.
As a
member of the AB at the time, I signaled my desire to speak, but was not
recognized by the President. Discussion was artificially limited to
30 minutes and the few who were allowed to speak were limited to five
minutes each. This was probably the most important AB meeting during my decade
or so on the Board, yet this false sense of urgency cut off debate when many
people still had ideas to share.
That AB
meeting – and its aftermath - were far and away the most acrimonious I have
ever seen. The experience was at odds with the generally collegial nature
of the typical AB meeting.
Even
after their victory, some members of the winning side could not resist the
temptation to engage in unseemly sarcastic eye rolling and unprofessional ad
hominem taunts.
As the
meeting was breaking up, I was dismayed to see one member of the winning side
(a former AB President) exhibit particularly nasty, bullying treatment of a
highly competent, professional woman AB member. This brilliant, extremely
accomplished woman has devoted years to the College for love of Reed. The white
male former AB President’s disrespectful attitude and sarcastic demeanor
reduced her to tears.
The
only thing worse than a bad loser is a bad winner.
This is
the "leadership" that wishes to consolidate power in its own hands
and severely limit participation by the Chapters in the doings of the Alumni
Board..
Statement of Opposition from Bill Nicholson '78
I am writing to urge rejection of the proposed amendments to the Reed College Alumni Association’s Constitution.
See the statement of opponents: https://reedalumni.blogspot.com/2018/12/statement-of-opponents-to-proposed.html
- Amending a Constitution is a major step which should not be undertaken absent compelling evidence that the existing document is hopelessly flawed. The proponents of the changes have not presented such evidence.
- The major effect of the proposed Constitutional changes would be the anti-democratic disenfranchisement of the Chapters. Disenfranchisement would be the result of reducing Chapter representation on the Alumni Board. Further, overworked Chapter heads would become members of a separate Chapters Committee - a new layer of bureaucracy.
- Adoption of the proposed changes would result in a significant diminution of alumni control over the Alumni Association. Fewer Chapter member seats on the AB would mean fewer grass roots alumni would be able to serve on the Alumni Board. Control of the Alumni Association would become even more concentrated in the hands of the Executive Committee - a self-appointed minority answerable only to themselves.
I urge rejection of the ill-advised and anti-democratic proposed changes in the Reed College Alumni Association’s Constitution.
See the statement of opponents: https://reedalumni.blogspot.com/2018/12/statement-of-opponents-to-proposed.html
- Amending a Constitution is a major step which should not be undertaken absent compelling evidence that the existing document is hopelessly flawed. The proponents of the changes have not presented such evidence.
- The major effect of the proposed Constitutional changes would be the anti-democratic disenfranchisement of the Chapters. Disenfranchisement would be the result of reducing Chapter representation on the Alumni Board. Further, overworked Chapter heads would become members of a separate Chapters Committee - a new layer of bureaucracy.
- Adoption of the proposed changes would result in a significant diminution of alumni control over the Alumni Association. Fewer Chapter member seats on the AB would mean fewer grass roots alumni would be able to serve on the Alumni Board. Control of the Alumni Association would become even more concentrated in the hands of the Executive Committee - a self-appointed minority answerable only to themselves.
I urge rejection of the ill-advised and anti-democratic proposed changes in the Reed College Alumni Association’s Constitution.
Monday, January 7, 2019
The final rush to pass the changes resulted in unintended errors and oddities
One of the major talking points of the proponents of the package of constitutional amendments which are the subject of the pending ratification referendum is that the proposed changes were under discussion for nine months before they were finally put to a vote. But that assertion is highly misleading.
It is true that the proposal to cut chapter representation on the Alumni Board down to three members, selected by an independent committee of all chapters, was first put forward at an Alumni Board meeting in September 2016, and was not finally adopted until the Alumni Board meeting on June 9, 2017. But the actual text of what was adopted was presented much later than that. This happened because, at the April Board meeting, Alumni Board president announced that any proposed changes that were to be put up for a vote in June had to be provided no later than May 6, 2017, to a “working group” that was supposed to engage in a back-and-forth the proponents of any change to ensure their technical sufficiency. The “working group” was then supposed to provide the final proposals to the full Alumni Board at least a a week before the final board meeting at which the proposals would be put to a vote. This so-called working group was in fact a group of proponents of the leadership’s proposal, and there was no back and forth between that group and the author of the chapter leaders’ counterproposal. It was only in the small hours of Sunday June 3 that the final proposals were distributed, in advance of the voting on Saturday June 9.
That left little time to analyze the new package of amendments, and not nearly enough time was allotted for discussion at the Alumni Board meeting, which had to end promptly so that Board members could get to the panel discussion celebrating the 25th Anniversary of Multicultural Resource Center. Bill Nicholson’s post is particularly telling on the limitation of discussion, and the impatience of the Alumni Board majority take the vote as soon as possible.
Major Differences
And the leadership’s proposal (dubbed the “past presidents” proposal), was very significantly different from the proposed changes that were put forward in September 2016. Instead of the chapters committee being able to select three representatives which would, simply by virtue of that selection, become members of the alumni board, under the new procedure, chapter representatives were to be subject to the following Rube Goldberg-esq procedure: the chapters committee (now renamed a chapter steering organization) nominate three chapter directors by November 15, for a one-year term beginning the following July (with a maximum of three one-year terms). These nominations are due at the same time as the five at-large directors, nominated for three-year terms beginning the next July (with no limit to the number of terms), and the executive committee members, also for terms beginning in July and also with no limit to the number of terms.
After November 15, all alums get the chance to run against the nominees, whether nominees fo at-large director positions, the executive committee positions, OR the chapter director positions. Even if there is no opposition candidate nominated, the terms of the nominees begins only the following July. If there is a contested election for any of the positions, then balloting occurs among all alums (whether or not they are in chapters – that is, all alums get to vote even on the chapter directors). BUT..... no matter whether it is the chapters organization nominee or some other candidate that wins the election for chapters director, the chapters committee gets the final say on which candidate would actually serve the one-year terms as chapters director.
There has never been any explanation for why, given that the chapters organization gets the final say on who serves as chapter director for a one-year term beginning the following July, the nominees selected by the chapters organization have to stand for election in the first place, or for that matter why the chapters organization nominees should have to wait until the following July to begin to serve.
Another change in the language was that, for the first time, there was a limitation set on the number of terms that could be served by a representative of the chapters. The claim was that all directors would have term limits, but this claim was false.
Consequence of the Change
The new procedure for selecting the three chapter representatives had some serious consequences that were not noticed at the time. The most serious one is what some of us have dubbed “the transition problem” – the fact, now admitted by the amendments’ proponents, that once the existing chapter representatives are removed by the passage of the amendments, no new chapter representatives can be added to the Alumni Board until July 2020.
Moreover, the changed procedure does not provide an effective way of dealing with possible vacancies. Under the existing constitution, if a representative of one of the chapters resigns, the chapter can simply designated a replacement. But under the amendments, if adopted, it is the president of the Alumni Board who gets to fill the vacancy; the amendments do not commit this vacancy to someone selected by the chapters organization,
It is true that the proposal to cut chapter representation on the Alumni Board down to three members, selected by an independent committee of all chapters, was first put forward at an Alumni Board meeting in September 2016, and was not finally adopted until the Alumni Board meeting on June 9, 2017. But the actual text of what was adopted was presented much later than that. This happened because, at the April Board meeting, Alumni Board president announced that any proposed changes that were to be put up for a vote in June had to be provided no later than May 6, 2017, to a “working group” that was supposed to engage in a back-and-forth the proponents of any change to ensure their technical sufficiency. The “working group” was then supposed to provide the final proposals to the full Alumni Board at least a a week before the final board meeting at which the proposals would be put to a vote. This so-called working group was in fact a group of proponents of the leadership’s proposal, and there was no back and forth between that group and the author of the chapter leaders’ counterproposal. It was only in the small hours of Sunday June 3 that the final proposals were distributed, in advance of the voting on Saturday June 9.
That left little time to analyze the new package of amendments, and not nearly enough time was allotted for discussion at the Alumni Board meeting, which had to end promptly so that Board members could get to the panel discussion celebrating the 25th Anniversary of Multicultural Resource Center. Bill Nicholson’s post is particularly telling on the limitation of discussion, and the impatience of the Alumni Board majority take the vote as soon as possible.
Major Differences
And the leadership’s proposal (dubbed the “past presidents” proposal), was very significantly different from the proposed changes that were put forward in September 2016. Instead of the chapters committee being able to select three representatives which would, simply by virtue of that selection, become members of the alumni board, under the new procedure, chapter representatives were to be subject to the following Rube Goldberg-esq procedure: the chapters committee (now renamed a chapter steering organization) nominate three chapter directors by November 15, for a one-year term beginning the following July (with a maximum of three one-year terms). These nominations are due at the same time as the five at-large directors, nominated for three-year terms beginning the next July (with no limit to the number of terms), and the executive committee members, also for terms beginning in July and also with no limit to the number of terms.
After November 15, all alums get the chance to run against the nominees, whether nominees fo at-large director positions, the executive committee positions, OR the chapter director positions. Even if there is no opposition candidate nominated, the terms of the nominees begins only the following July. If there is a contested election for any of the positions, then balloting occurs among all alums (whether or not they are in chapters – that is, all alums get to vote even on the chapter directors). BUT..... no matter whether it is the chapters organization nominee or some other candidate that wins the election for chapters director, the chapters committee gets the final say on which candidate would actually serve the one-year terms as chapters director.
There has never been any explanation for why, given that the chapters organization gets the final say on who serves as chapter director for a one-year term beginning the following July, the nominees selected by the chapters organization have to stand for election in the first place, or for that matter why the chapters organization nominees should have to wait until the following July to begin to serve.
Another change in the language was that, for the first time, there was a limitation set on the number of terms that could be served by a representative of the chapters. The claim was that all directors would have term limits, but this claim was false.
Consequence of the Change
The new procedure for selecting the three chapter representatives had some serious consequences that were not noticed at the time. The most serious one is what some of us have dubbed “the transition problem” – the fact, now admitted by the amendments’ proponents, that once the existing chapter representatives are removed by the passage of the amendments, no new chapter representatives can be added to the Alumni Board until July 2020.
Moreover, the changed procedure does not provide an effective way of dealing with possible vacancies. Under the existing constitution, if a representative of one of the chapters resigns, the chapter can simply designated a replacement. But under the amendments, if adopted, it is the president of the Alumni Board who gets to fill the vacancy; the amendments do not commit this vacancy to someone selected by the chapters organization,
In whose interest? The board should focus on the interests of alumni, not just the college
Back in September of 2017, when the proposal to cut the chapters out of full representation on the Alumni Board was first put forward, there were two main rationales. One was “streamlining” – from the perspective of some who are involved in business organizations, the Alumni Board was said to be too large to be effective, so the numbers had to be cut – and those numbers were to be achieved by having fewer chapter representatives. But why not just down on the number of at-large representatives? Why not say the Alumni Trustees did not have to be members of the Alumni Board? Well, the explanation for that was that the nominating committee (selected by the central leadership of the Board) would be working with the Alumni Office staff to focus on nominating new at-large members who could be helpful in advancing the college’s objectives. In his own recent statement in support of the changes, John Sheehy has confirmed that this is the real agenda -- he chastises opponents for wanting to help alumni instead of trying only to help the college itself as an institution.
That latter rationale put some of us off. The college’s objectives? Shouldn’t the alumni board of directors be focused first and foremost on advancing the objectives of alumni, as best as we might see it? These two interests are often aligned, but not always. Sometimes, the interests (or views) of the alumni may be at odd with the interests (or views) of the college’s staff.
One such occasion, which came up at the very outset of John Kroger’s presidency, was during the controversy that arose after Kroger’s ham-handed intervention to quash some Paideia courses that he viewed as being at odds with his substance-control objectives. Many of us on the alumni board, especially representatives of many of the chapters, felt that we should express solidarity with the Paideia czar in opposition to Kroger’s intervention, and a resolution was put forward to that effect. The executive committee reacted with alarm, insisting that the Alumni Board had no role in expressing dissatisfaction with the operation of the college. Our resolution of disapproval was voted down; might an early alumni vote of disapproval have had some impact in avoiding some of the disappointments of the Kroger era?
Another example of divergence has to do with alumni career networking. One of the most interesting endeavor undertaken by the alumni leadership during the past ten years was the development of Working Weekend, which began as an entirely alumni-led effort to bring large numbers of alumni back to campus, in February of each of several years, for two days of panel presentations, aimed at students, but composed of alumni working in different fields. Working Weekend was a wonderful opportunity for students to meet alumni, but it was also a great opportunity for alumni working in the same field to connect with each other. After the first couple of years, the college’s own career placement staff slowly took control of planning for the Weekends; and after Alice Harra was hired to run what became known as the Center for Life Beyond Reed, the college decided to kill the operation, because CLBR was developing a different model for career planning for students; and the college decided, at the same time, that it had no commitment to helping alumni a substantial amount of time out of the college with career placement. Now, this may well have been an entirely sensible move for the college from the perspective of its services to students, and its allocation of resources, but it was a serious blow to the objective of alumni career networking. The Alumni Association needs to see the advancement of alumni interests as its main goal, and alumni leadership need to be able to press the college to provide better services to alumni. (Note: there has been vague talk by college staff, speaking at meetings of the Reed Career Alliance, a current Alumni Board committee, of reviving Working Weekend next year, in 2020)
As the executive committee approached the final vote on the proposed changes, the rationale for the change made a subtle change from selecting nominees who fit the priorities of the college to selecting nominees who fit the priorities of the Alumni Board. But so long as the selection of nominees is done by a handful of unelected insiders in consultation with alumni office staff, there may be little difference between the two. Full representation of the chapters on the Alumni Board is needed to ensure a modicum of independence from control by the college’s staff, which is not always in the interest of the alumni.
That latter rationale put some of us off. The college’s objectives? Shouldn’t the alumni board of directors be focused first and foremost on advancing the objectives of alumni, as best as we might see it? These two interests are often aligned, but not always. Sometimes, the interests (or views) of the alumni may be at odd with the interests (or views) of the college’s staff.
One such occasion, which came up at the very outset of John Kroger’s presidency, was during the controversy that arose after Kroger’s ham-handed intervention to quash some Paideia courses that he viewed as being at odds with his substance-control objectives. Many of us on the alumni board, especially representatives of many of the chapters, felt that we should express solidarity with the Paideia czar in opposition to Kroger’s intervention, and a resolution was put forward to that effect. The executive committee reacted with alarm, insisting that the Alumni Board had no role in expressing dissatisfaction with the operation of the college. Our resolution of disapproval was voted down; might an early alumni vote of disapproval have had some impact in avoiding some of the disappointments of the Kroger era?
Another example of divergence has to do with alumni career networking. One of the most interesting endeavor undertaken by the alumni leadership during the past ten years was the development of Working Weekend, which began as an entirely alumni-led effort to bring large numbers of alumni back to campus, in February of each of several years, for two days of panel presentations, aimed at students, but composed of alumni working in different fields. Working Weekend was a wonderful opportunity for students to meet alumni, but it was also a great opportunity for alumni working in the same field to connect with each other. After the first couple of years, the college’s own career placement staff slowly took control of planning for the Weekends; and after Alice Harra was hired to run what became known as the Center for Life Beyond Reed, the college decided to kill the operation, because CLBR was developing a different model for career planning for students; and the college decided, at the same time, that it had no commitment to helping alumni a substantial amount of time out of the college with career placement. Now, this may well have been an entirely sensible move for the college from the perspective of its services to students, and its allocation of resources, but it was a serious blow to the objective of alumni career networking. The Alumni Association needs to see the advancement of alumni interests as its main goal, and alumni leadership need to be able to press the college to provide better services to alumni. (Note: there has been vague talk by college staff, speaking at meetings of the Reed Career Alliance, a current Alumni Board committee, of reviving Working Weekend next year, in 2020)
As the executive committee approached the final vote on the proposed changes, the rationale for the change made a subtle change from selecting nominees who fit the priorities of the college to selecting nominees who fit the priorities of the Alumni Board. But so long as the selection of nominees is done by a handful of unelected insiders in consultation with alumni office staff, there may be little difference between the two. Full representation of the chapters on the Alumni Board is needed to ensure a modicum of independence from control by the college’s staff, which is not always in the interest of the alumni.
Saturday, December 29, 2018
Statement from Marcia Yaross '73
My objection to the proposed constitutional amendments is informed by nearly a decade on the Alumni Board: as Outreach Committee Chair, Nominations Committee member, Alumna Trustee, plus chapter steering committee member. While I applaud the proponents’ desire to improve the AB’s effectiveness, I find the following troublesome:
• Absence of a clear “problem statement” makes it difficult to assess whether the proposed changes will help. While the “Proposal” states the “goal is to increase alignment,” what is misaligned and how the proposal will solve the undefined problem are unclear.
• While the “Proposal” calls for “all alumni board members [to] have term limits,” it only limits terms for Chapter Directors and Alumni Trustees. The latter limit derives from the Reed Board of Trustees governance rules, but the former appears arbitrary.
• Removal of most chapter leaders from AB membership has alienated several hard-working, committed chapter volunteers at a time when other controversies still reverberate within the alumni community. I recommend the AB work to heal rifts in our community through more inclusive, not exclusionary, actions.
• Alternatively, Nominations Committee focus on matching skills needed for each AB position, plus training/coaching on effective meeting management, may better address AB effectiveness concerns.
Respectfully,
Marcia Yaross, ‘73
• Absence of a clear “problem statement” makes it difficult to assess whether the proposed changes will help. While the “Proposal” states the “goal is to increase alignment,” what is misaligned and how the proposal will solve the undefined problem are unclear.
• While the “Proposal” calls for “all alumni board members [to] have term limits,” it only limits terms for Chapter Directors and Alumni Trustees. The latter limit derives from the Reed Board of Trustees governance rules, but the former appears arbitrary.
• Removal of most chapter leaders from AB membership has alienated several hard-working, committed chapter volunteers at a time when other controversies still reverberate within the alumni community. I recommend the AB work to heal rifts in our community through more inclusive, not exclusionary, actions.
• Alternatively, Nominations Committee focus on matching skills needed for each AB position, plus training/coaching on effective meeting management, may better address AB effectiveness concerns.
Respectfully,
Marcia Yaross, ‘73
Alternate Approaches to Choosing Alumni Association Leadership
by Paul Alan Levy ‘72
The post from Friederike Keating, which suggests both that the alumni board is too large to be effective but also that the board needs to provide representation to more strains of alumni activism, leads me to provide the following reflection on paths not taken by the current proposed amendments to the alumni association’s constitution.
When the proposal to eliminate representatives from each of the chapters on the alumni board was first put forward in the fall of 2017, one of the rationales offered by the proponents of the change was that the alumni board was too large to operate effectively; elimination of chapter representation was said to represent a necessary form of streamlining. Of course, there was no necessary connection between the objective of cutting the size and eliminating chapter representation – why not, instead, cut down on the number of at-large members (fifteen of them, with five elected each year)?
Another alternative that was put forward was to keep roughly the same number of alumni board members but to achieve a degree of streamlining by expanding the Board’s Executive Committee – currently consisting of the secretary, vice–president, president, and immediate past president of the alumni board – by adding the chairs of each of the functioning committees – currently, the Committee for Young Alumni, the Diversity and Inclusion Committee, the Reed Career Alliance and the Chapters Committee. To make sure that this leadership represented a bottom-up democratic selection process instead of the current top-down process whereby the Alumni Board’s president chooses the committee chairs, the alternate proposals was for the committees to choose their own chairs.
One that sort of streamlined leadership structure was in place, it could have been possible to expand alumni participation in the alumni board by drawing in representatives from the affinity networks that have begun to form among alumni — among alumni of color, STEM femmes, legal professionals, journalists, Reedies in finance, Reedies for social change, and the like. That might have made the Board larger, although an alternative would have been to reduce the number of at-large board members.
To my own mind, the alumni board ought to be the gathering place where alums who are active in building and supporting the various activities of the alumni community can compare notes, and find ways to collaborate as well as to relate their activities to the college and the current students. Membership ought to be generated from the bottom up, rather than being selected by the current top-down process to which the representatives of the chapters are now the only exception. During the last years before Todd Hesse and Mike Teskey were pushed out of their alumni office positions, I had been hearing about such a possible expansion of the alumni board. Sadly, in the event the Board’s leadership decided to go in a different direction.
Indeed, the alternate amendment proposed, as well, that the nominating committee not limit itself to selecting a single candidate for each of the at-large and executive committee positions, One of the nicest developments at the alumni board over the past few years has been the increase in the number of alums who have wanted to be considered to be nominated for election to at-large positions. Reports from the nominating committee in recent years mentioned their having made selections from a pool of 45 or even 50 possible candidates. Why not, then, charge the nominating committee with putting forward at least two candidates for each at large position, and letting the alumni members choose among those candidates in an election? A similar principle might call for nominating multiple candidates for the executive committee positions.
Unfortunately, the proponents of the alumni constitution amendments decided to change in the direction of less democracy rather than more.
The post from Friederike Keating, which suggests both that the alumni board is too large to be effective but also that the board needs to provide representation to more strains of alumni activism, leads me to provide the following reflection on paths not taken by the current proposed amendments to the alumni association’s constitution.
When the proposal to eliminate representatives from each of the chapters on the alumni board was first put forward in the fall of 2017, one of the rationales offered by the proponents of the change was that the alumni board was too large to operate effectively; elimination of chapter representation was said to represent a necessary form of streamlining. Of course, there was no necessary connection between the objective of cutting the size and eliminating chapter representation – why not, instead, cut down on the number of at-large members (fifteen of them, with five elected each year)?
Another alternative that was put forward was to keep roughly the same number of alumni board members but to achieve a degree of streamlining by expanding the Board’s Executive Committee – currently consisting of the secretary, vice–president, president, and immediate past president of the alumni board – by adding the chairs of each of the functioning committees – currently, the Committee for Young Alumni, the Diversity and Inclusion Committee, the Reed Career Alliance and the Chapters Committee. To make sure that this leadership represented a bottom-up democratic selection process instead of the current top-down process whereby the Alumni Board’s president chooses the committee chairs, the alternate proposals was for the committees to choose their own chairs.
One that sort of streamlined leadership structure was in place, it could have been possible to expand alumni participation in the alumni board by drawing in representatives from the affinity networks that have begun to form among alumni — among alumni of color, STEM femmes, legal professionals, journalists, Reedies in finance, Reedies for social change, and the like. That might have made the Board larger, although an alternative would have been to reduce the number of at-large board members.
To my own mind, the alumni board ought to be the gathering place where alums who are active in building and supporting the various activities of the alumni community can compare notes, and find ways to collaborate as well as to relate their activities to the college and the current students. Membership ought to be generated from the bottom up, rather than being selected by the current top-down process to which the representatives of the chapters are now the only exception. During the last years before Todd Hesse and Mike Teskey were pushed out of their alumni office positions, I had been hearing about such a possible expansion of the alumni board. Sadly, in the event the Board’s leadership decided to go in a different direction.
Indeed, the alternate amendment proposed, as well, that the nominating committee not limit itself to selecting a single candidate for each of the at-large and executive committee positions, One of the nicest developments at the alumni board over the past few years has been the increase in the number of alums who have wanted to be considered to be nominated for election to at-large positions. Reports from the nominating committee in recent years mentioned their having made selections from a pool of 45 or even 50 possible candidates. Why not, then, charge the nominating committee with putting forward at least two candidates for each at large position, and letting the alumni members choose among those candidates in an election? A similar principle might call for nominating multiple candidates for the executive committee positions.
Unfortunately, the proponents of the alumni constitution amendments decided to change in the direction of less democracy rather than more.
Wednesday, December 19, 2018
The transition problem -- how poorly crafted language in the proposed amendments cuts out all directors representing chapters until July 1, 2020
The final drafters of the proposed amendments included a serious mistake: though the plan was to cut the alumni association chapters down to having 3 representatives on the alumni board of directors (ABD), in fact their amendments eliminate ALL chapter representation on the ABD for the first 18 months after the referendum is done (if their proposal passes). This is “the transition problem.”
Close Reading of the Documents
Specifically, one of the last minute changes that was made in the proposed amendments that had been under discussion since the fall, on the eve of the ABD meeting in June 2018, was to create an odd mechanism for identifying the three representatives to which the chapters are to be limited under the proposed amendments. Instead of simply being selected by the proposed new body called the Chapter Steering Organization (“CSO”), its selectees were made subject to the same nominating and election process as the at-large members as well as the executive committee members and the alumni trustee. (Articles IV(1)(c), VI(3), and VII(5) et seq.). Under this language, instead of being able to begin serving immediately, the CSO nominees will have to be submitted to the nominating committee which will be required to name them as the nominees for Chapter Director positions "on or before November 15." Then they will have to be identified in an official Reed publication as soon as possible after November 15; then there is a waiting period while there is an opportunity for other nominations, allowing any alum, even one who does not live in a chapter area, to run for one of the chapter representation positions. Then there is provision for the CSO to accept or reject the nominees who are elected. THEN the term of office for those representatives begins on July 1 following the election.
Let's assume that the proposed amendments are adopted in a referendum that will be completed in early February. By virtue of the change, all chapter representatives will be off the board. And yet the deadline for identifying Chapter Directors and publishing their names to the alumni membership, for terms to begin the following July 1, will be long past. Chapter Directors will have to be identified for publication to the membership on the following November 15 (2019), and then subjected to the election process preparatory to taking office on the following July 1, 2020. So, for a year and a half after the passage of the amendments, these provisions mean that the chapters will have NO representation on the board.
The Alumni Board Leadership Tried but Failed to Explain This Problem Away
These were shared in a comment thread in the Reed (u) Facebook group here (only the 4400 members of that Facebook group can view these). Then you can see in the comment thread a long back and forth between Paul Levy ‘72, a public interest litigator who is one of the opponents of the changes, and Darlene Pasieczny '01, a securities law litigator who favors the changes and has been the leaders’ technical point person. Initially, she denies that the language of the amendments had this meaning., but pleads that she is in a hurry and will respond in detail later; then she bravely says that the language does not do this but won’t explain why; then finally she asks Levy to agree with her assumption that the Alumni Board could just ignore the language of the amendments to add chapter representatives to take care of this problem. See also this post (again, accessible only to those who belong to the Reed (u) Facebook group).
But that cannot be right. The reason you adopt a constitution is to LIMIT the power of the ABD to monkey with selection of leaders. The way to deal with the problem that the leadership created is to vote the amendments down, sending them back to the drawing board if they still insist that having too many chapter representatives on the ABD is a problem that needs fixing.
How This Mistake Was Made
This post explains how this last minute error came to be made – alumni leaders put forward last-minute changes in the language of their proposal, and were in such a hurry to ram this vote through (they knew they had enough votes on the Board) that they did not leave enough time to study their final proposed language, and refused to allow enough discussion, before it was put to a vote.
Close Reading of the Documents
Specifically, one of the last minute changes that was made in the proposed amendments that had been under discussion since the fall, on the eve of the ABD meeting in June 2018, was to create an odd mechanism for identifying the three representatives to which the chapters are to be limited under the proposed amendments. Instead of simply being selected by the proposed new body called the Chapter Steering Organization (“CSO”), its selectees were made subject to the same nominating and election process as the at-large members as well as the executive committee members and the alumni trustee. (Articles IV(1)(c), VI(3), and VII(5) et seq.). Under this language, instead of being able to begin serving immediately, the CSO nominees will have to be submitted to the nominating committee which will be required to name them as the nominees for Chapter Director positions "on or before November 15." Then they will have to be identified in an official Reed publication as soon as possible after November 15; then there is a waiting period while there is an opportunity for other nominations, allowing any alum, even one who does not live in a chapter area, to run for one of the chapter representation positions. Then there is provision for the CSO to accept or reject the nominees who are elected. THEN the term of office for those representatives begins on July 1 following the election.
Let's assume that the proposed amendments are adopted in a referendum that will be completed in early February. By virtue of the change, all chapter representatives will be off the board. And yet the deadline for identifying Chapter Directors and publishing their names to the alumni membership, for terms to begin the following July 1, will be long past. Chapter Directors will have to be identified for publication to the membership on the following November 15 (2019), and then subjected to the election process preparatory to taking office on the following July 1, 2020. So, for a year and a half after the passage of the amendments, these provisions mean that the chapters will have NO representation on the board.
The Alumni Board Leadership Tried but Failed to Explain This Problem Away
These were shared in a comment thread in the Reed (u) Facebook group here (only the 4400 members of that Facebook group can view these). Then you can see in the comment thread a long back and forth between Paul Levy ‘72, a public interest litigator who is one of the opponents of the changes, and Darlene Pasieczny '01, a securities law litigator who favors the changes and has been the leaders’ technical point person. Initially, she denies that the language of the amendments had this meaning., but pleads that she is in a hurry and will respond in detail later; then she bravely says that the language does not do this but won’t explain why; then finally she asks Levy to agree with her assumption that the Alumni Board could just ignore the language of the amendments to add chapter representatives to take care of this problem. See also this post (again, accessible only to those who belong to the Reed (u) Facebook group).
But that cannot be right. The reason you adopt a constitution is to LIMIT the power of the ABD to monkey with selection of leaders. The way to deal with the problem that the leadership created is to vote the amendments down, sending them back to the drawing board if they still insist that having too many chapter representatives on the ABD is a problem that needs fixing.
How This Mistake Was Made
This post explains how this last minute error came to be made – alumni leaders put forward last-minute changes in the language of their proposal, and were in such a hurry to ram this vote through (they knew they had enough votes on the Board) that they did not leave enough time to study their final proposed language, and refused to allow enough discussion, before it was put to a vote.
Tuesday, December 18, 2018
A different perspective: Statement from Friederike Keating ‘85
A different perspective: Statement from Friederike Keating ‘85
Friederike Keating, one of the moderators of the Reed (unofficial) Facebook group, explained her reasons for voting against the proposes amendments in one of the comment threads in that group (those who belong to the group can see it here) She has kindly consented to allow the following statement to be posted here. The group of opponents who sponsor this blog do not agree about all the following, but, in the event that the changes are voted down, we will all have to think about what comes next. As we see it, a multiplicity of viewpoints on that prospect is to be welcomed.
"I will vote against the proposal but for different reasons than those in your statement, and with a different vision. My vision is of a Board that is composed of reps from different areas of the alumni association and is streamlined so that it can make some strategic decisions after being advised by those reps, and then delegate the work back out to the contingents/committees/subgroups represented by those reps. It's like a sleeker, more efficient kind of Board.
"With that in mind:
I am in agreement with the idea of reduced representation of chapter leaders, because having all chapter leaders on the Board seems unwieldy.
I am in agreement with the idea of a chapter council that sends reps to the Board.
"However,
I think 3 is too few.
I think there should also be fewer At Large and Trustee members,
I think there should be equal terms and term limits for all
"My vision may not be workable for an organization that suffers from varying levels of enthusiasm and engagement and needs to use all the talent it can, and I am certainly not in a position to make any strong recommendations due to my lack of involvement (though I think of myself as having worked in one aspect of alumni relations quite diligently, that of social media/fb, and I think that may well deserve more attention in the alumni association's world)."
Friederike Keating, one of the moderators of the Reed (unofficial) Facebook group, explained her reasons for voting against the proposes amendments in one of the comment threads in that group (those who belong to the group can see it here) She has kindly consented to allow the following statement to be posted here. The group of opponents who sponsor this blog do not agree about all the following, but, in the event that the changes are voted down, we will all have to think about what comes next. As we see it, a multiplicity of viewpoints on that prospect is to be welcomed.
"I will vote against the proposal but for different reasons than those in your statement, and with a different vision. My vision is of a Board that is composed of reps from different areas of the alumni association and is streamlined so that it can make some strategic decisions after being advised by those reps, and then delegate the work back out to the contingents/committees/subgroups represented by those reps. It's like a sleeker, more efficient kind of Board.
"With that in mind:
I am in agreement with the idea of reduced representation of chapter leaders, because having all chapter leaders on the Board seems unwieldy.
I am in agreement with the idea of a chapter council that sends reps to the Board.
"However,
I think 3 is too few.
I think there should also be fewer At Large and Trustee members,
I think there should be equal terms and term limits for all
"My vision may not be workable for an organization that suffers from varying levels of enthusiasm and engagement and needs to use all the talent it can, and I am certainly not in a position to make any strong recommendations due to my lack of involvement (though I think of myself as having worked in one aspect of alumni relations quite diligently, that of social media/fb, and I think that may well deserve more attention in the alumni association's world)."
Wednesday, December 5, 2018
Statement of objection by James Kahan '64
My
objection to the proposed Alumni Association (AA) constitutional changes is
informed by my highly active volunteer participation, including service on the Alumni
Board of Directors (ABD). I helped write
the group statement in opposition, and here add further objections.
The
self-perpetuation of the ABD solely through the closely-selected Nominating
Committee is anti-democratic; instead, the AA as a whole should choose its
representatives in as transparent and democratic a manner as possible. A way to accomplish this is to use modern
communications technology to hold an annual ranked-choice election for:
·
One alumni trustee to serve a four-year term,
·
One member of the ABD Executive Committee to serve a
four-year term, and
·
Five at-large members of the ABD, each to serve a
three-year term.
Alumni
wishing to serve would submit a short statement of why they wish to do so; they
might possibly also be asked to name up to ten people who endorse their
candidacy.
“Alignment
of interests”—used to justify the proposed changes—should be accomplished by
coordination of bottom-up ideas instead of top-down diktats. Indeed, to be faithful to the AA’s mission, such coordination
should be the primary function of the ABD.
James
Kahan, ‘64
Tuesday, December 4, 2018
Where Reed alums live
Our data on the fraction of alums living in chapter areas came from Reed's Office of Alumni Programs, as follows. The cohorts represent groupings of time since graduation
| Total Living Alumni | ||
| Cohort 1 | 3881 | |
| Cohort 2 | 4613 | |
| Cohort 3 | 4499 | |
| Cohort 4 | 4766 | |
| TOTAL | 17759 | |
| By chapter | ||
| Boston | ||
| Cohort 1 | 176 | |
| Cohort 2 | 153 | |
| Cohort 3 | 151 | |
| Cohort 4 | 162 | |
| TOTAL | 642 | |
| % of Total | 4% | |
| Chicago | ||
| Cohort 1 | 113 | |
| Cohort 2 | 110 | |
| Cohort 3 | 103 | |
| Cohort 4 | 79 | |
| TOTAL | 405 | |
| % of Total | 2% | |
| Europe | ||
| Cohort 1 | 35 | |
| Cohort 2 | 84 | |
| Cohort 3 | 85 | |
| Cohort 4 | 56 | |
| TOTAL | 260 | |
| % of Total | 1% | |
| Los Angeles | ||
| Cohort 1 | 288 | |
| Cohort 2 | 235 | |
| Cohort 3 | 219 | |
| Cohort 4 | 276 | |
| TOTAL | 1018 | |
| % of Total | 6% | |
| New York City | ||
| Cohort 1 | 367 | |
| Cohort 2 | 364 | |
| Cohort 3 | 313 | |
| Cohort 4 | 266 | |
| TOTAL | 1310 | |
| % of Total | 7% | |
| Portland | ||
| Cohort 1 | 779 | |
| Cohort 2 | 894 | |
| Cohort 3 | 989 | |
| Cohort 4 | 895 | |
| TOTAL | 3557 | |
| % of Total | 20% | |
| San Francisco | ||
| Cohort 1 | 416 | |
| Cohort 2 | 517 | |
| Cohort 3 | 491 | |
| Cohort 4 | 568 | |
| TOTAL | 1992 | |
| % of Total | 11% | |
| Seattle | ||
| Cohort 1 | 228 | |
| Cohort 2 | 313 | |
| Cohort 3 | 414 | |
| Cohort 4 | 410 | |
| TOTAL | 1365 | |
| % of Total | 8% | |
| Triangle (NC) | ||
| Cohort 1 | 44 | |
| Cohort 2 | 58 | |
| Cohort 3 | 49 | |
| Cohort 4 | 35 | |
| TOTAL | 186 | |
| % of Total | 1% | |
| Washington DC | ||
| Cohort 1 | 141 | |
| Cohort 2 | 190 | |
| Cohort 3 | 194 | |
| Cohort 4 | 200 | |
| TOTAL | 725 | |
| % of Total | 4% | |
| Everyone else | ||
| Cohort 1 | 1294 | |
| Cohort 2 | 1695 | |
| Cohort 3 | 1491 | |
| Cohort 4 | 1819 | |
| TOTAL | 6299 | |
| % of Total | 35% | |
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
This blog will carry the views of Reed College alumni who believe that the proposal by the existing leadership of the Reed College Alumni As...
-
Here is the current list of authors and signers (as of January 18): ...
-
This blog will carry the views of Reed College alumni who believe that the proposal by the existing leadership of the Reed College Alumni As...
-
Back in September of 2017, when the proposal to cut the chapters out of full representation on the Alumni Board was first put forward, there...